Elliott Advisors (UK) Limited Response to Vivendi Statements
The latest statements from Vivendi and the Board it controls at Telecom Italia (“TIM” or “the Company”), defending its failed stewardship and attacking the Board of Statutory Auditors, reinforce Elliott’s view that TIM needs a Board composed of truly independent directors who will finally put the interests of shareholders first as it works to improve governance and performance.
Under Vivendi’s control, TIM has experienced profound and persistent share price underperformance, made repeated strategic missteps, operated with no regard for proper governance and exhibited numerous conflicts of interest.
Elliott believes Vivendi’s statement of April 17 (extracts of which appear below), lacks substance and is replete with platitudes that do not remotely address the issues which have plagued TIM under Vivendi’s stewardship. Most notably, Vivendi repeatedly refers to itself as the “main” shareholder in TIM. It is in fact not; it is merely the largest shareholder, and Elliott believes Vivendi’s interests are no more important than those of other TIM shareholders. Furthermore, contrary to Vivendi’s assertions, Elliott is strongly of the view that it is never premature for companies to create value for their shareholders. Finally, when Italian authorities are publicly stating that Vivendi is an “awful” shareholder, it is clear that the status quo is untenable.
It is time for change at Telecom Italia. Elliott believes shareholders need a united board, not one divided and mired in litigation with its own statutory auditors. Shareholders deserve the opportunity to unlock significant value by supporting Elliott’s proposal, which begins with electing a truly independent Board of Directors on April 24.
Extracts from Vivendi’s April 17 statement:
“Telecom Italia had lost more than 70% of its market value in
the previous ten years before Vivendi came on board.”
The negative trend in TIM’s stock price performance has accelerated since Vivendi nominees joined the Board in December 2015. In a little over two years, TIM’s stock has fallen more than 35%1.
“Vivendi has taken an industrial approach to Telecom Italia
which is bringing a real competitive advantage.”
Vivendi’s “industrial approach” has benefited itself, as evidenced by related party transactions allowing Vivendi to reap benefits accruing to its group companies such as Canal Plus and Havas, to the detriment of TIM and its shareholders.
“Under Italian law and governance principles, as the main
shareholder of Telecom Italia Vivendi has acted in the interests of
the company as a whole and has ensured the Board and governance
structures of the business are in full compliance with law.”
There are numerous examples that show Vivendi has acted in its sole interest: these include the blocking of the savings share conversion; breaching both golden power and Gasparri law; appointing non-independent directors; and appointing managers with conflicting roles such as Michel Sibony. Mr. Sibony was appointed Head of the Procurement Unit and Real Estate Department at TIM’s March 6 2018 Board meeting, despite holding several functions within the Bolloré Group, Havas, and Vivendi (potential suppliers to TIM). He was also recently appointed Chief Value Officer at Vivendi.
“As the main shareholder in Telecom Italia, Vivendi can provide
stability and expertise while enabling other shareholders to invest
and participate in the future upside.”
It appears that Vivendi’s approach to telecom assets in the past (SFR, GVT, Maroc Telecom) has been to trade these businesses rather than to promote investment stability through long-term stewardship.
“Vivendi has catalysed a recovery in Telecom Italia’s share
price at a time when telecoms operators in Europe and globally have
suffered a savage derating. […] Telecom Italia stock has outperformed
peers by 17% since June 2017 (Stoxx Europe 600/Telcos index).”
Since Vivendi nominees joined the TIM board the stock has lost over 35% of its value, underperforming the Stoxx Europe 600/Telcos index (SXKP) by 20%. Even if one takes Vivendi’s reference point of June 2017, the outperformance vs. the index was less than 1%2.
“It is that recovery which is now at risk.”
Elliott is not proposing to overhaul Telecom Italia’s management team but rather to address a track record of poor governance and a lack of stewardship, systemic since Vivendi nominees were appointed to the board in December 2015.
“Elliott admitted in a recent document: 'Since 2016, TIM has
started to consistently deliver growing revenue and EBITDA.'”
This underscores Elliott’s point: management is not the source of the problem. The languishing share price performance and growing governance concerns need to be addressed.
“Yet it does not explain how that plan can be implemented with a
The very reason the existing board is divided today is because of Vivendi’s poor stewardship and disregard for best practice corporate governance. The current board is anything but united as evidenced by the recent 10-5 vote on the topic of litigating with the Company’s statutory auditors (the 10 directors who voted in favour of this resolution were each nominated by Vivendi). Elliott agrees a divided board is detrimental to the Company and its shareholders. This division strengthens Elliott’s case to replace six of Vivendi’s nominated directors with new independent and highly qualified board members on April 24.
“…nor does Elliott explain how it can help matters to impose a
new strategy on Amos Genish and his team without the support of the
company’s largest shareholder.”
Elliott is not imposing any strategic plan. Elliott is a shareholder and is proposing independent, highly qualified directors to replace selected Vivendi nominees on the Company’s board.
“To give one example, the deconsolidation of the network
business which has proven a failure in the few countries where it has
Elliott advocates that it is incumbent upon the independent board of directors to explore and evaluate various alternatives to unlock value for all shareholders. The Czech Republic, the only other European example of a voluntary network separation in the telecom sector, has created significant value for shareholders of O2 Czech (ServiceCo), as evidenced by total shareholder return of almost 400% since June 2015.3
“Perhaps Vivendi in the past underestimated some of Italy’s
In Elliott’s view, respecting the rule of law (the golden power and Gasparri law), respecting the rights of minority shareholders, appointing highly qualified, independent directors and respecting the board of statutory auditors are not unique features of Italy, but common features of advanced market economies.
“We recognize that the Italian government and regulators have an
important stake in ensuring that Telecom Italia is well run and able
to fulfil its role as the backbone of Italian communications
Vivendi has failed to cooperate with the regulator and the government not only in Telecom Italia but also in its previous attempted hostile takeover of Mediaset.
“Over time the conflict between certain investors’ demands for
quick fixes and the true interest of the Italian nation which lies in
a strong, independent Telecom Italia will become more apparent.”
Telecom Italia’s shareholders are focused on value creation for all shareholders, delivered by a strong management team, and overseen by a truly independent board with appropriate governance in place. The current slate proposed by Vivendi will, in Elliott’s view, be unable to foster the independent corporate governance that the company so crucially requires.
“Led by a main shareholder with a long-term industrial vision
and the necessary commitment, the management can focus on delivering
Elliott believes management should be led by the current CEO and the board of directors rather than by a single shareholder. Elliott has been unable to identify any previous example of a telecom company requiring a media company to control its board in order to create value for its shareholders.
“Vivendi has, we believe, demonstrated that commitment, and has
been a positive catalyst for change.”
Elliott believes share price underperformance, CONSOB investigations, independent directors’ and Italian ministers’ comments, clearly show that Vivendi has failed in its stewardship role and has failed to be a positive catalyst for shareholder value creation at TIM.
“We have proposed a slate of candidates for the Board who are
fully supportive of the management team and their approach.”
Elliott, along with proxy advisors Glass Lewis, ISS and Frontis Governance, believes its slate to be a material improvement to that put forward by Vivendi, in terms of credibility, suitable experience and the support it can provide the management team.
“In drawing up that slate we have listened attentively to the
views of others.”
Vivendi may have listened to the views of others but it has evidently ignored them: Vivendi has presented mostly the same directors who resigned in March 2018, including those whom they claim to be independent.
Elliott Management Corporation manages two multi-strategy funds which combined have approximately $35 billion of assets under management. Its flagship fund, Elliott Associates, L.P., was founded in 1977, making it one of the oldest funds of its kind under continuous management. The Elliott funds’ investors include pension plans, sovereign wealth funds, endowments, foundations, funds-of-funds, and employees of the firm. Elliott Advisors (UK) Limited is an affiliate of Elliott Management Corporation.
Our approach to TIM is consistent with our approach to many of our current and previous investments. We have invested a significant amount of time and resources into understanding TIM, including hiring numerous advisors and consultants with whom we have worked closely together with our business associates. We believe strongly in the value conclusions that we have drawn as a result of this effort.
|1||Calculated from 15-Dec-2015 to 05-Mar-2018 (latest undisturbed pricing date before Elliott interest in TIM was disclosed).|
|2||Calculated from 01-Jun-2017 to 05-Mar-2018 (latest undisturbed pricing date before Elliott interest in TIM was disclosed).|
|3||O2 Czech Republic (TELEC CP) total shareholder return since 01-Jun-2015 (date of CETIN separation) to 17-Apr-2018.|
Elliott Advisors (UK) Limited
Sarah Rajani CFA, +44 (0) 20 3009 1475
Verini & Associates
Marcella Verini, +39 (02) 4539 5500
+39 (06) 42171 201
+34 (91) 7012170
Om Business Wire
(c) 2018 Business Wire, Inc., All rights reserved.
Business Wire, a Berkshire Hathaway company, is the global leader in multiplatform press release distribution.
Følg saker fra Business Wire
Registrer deg med din epostadresse under for å få de nyeste sakene fra Business Wire på epost fortløpende. Du kan melde deg av når som helst.
Siste saker fra Business Wire
IDEMIA Provides Subscription Management Platform to dtac in Thailand to Offer eSIM Connected Watches to All Its Subscribers.14.12.2018 03:30 | Pressemelding
IDEMIA, the global leader in Augmented Identity, has been selected by dtac, the leading mobile operator in Thailand, to offer connectivity on eSIM connected watches. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20181213005934/en/ Credits : IDEMIA IDEMIA’s Subscription Management platform (or remote SIM provisioning) is the technology that remotely connects the embedded SIM of a smartwatch to dtac’s network without inserting a physical SIM card. Indeed, the IDEMIA Subscription Manager is a server which securely manages the lifecycle of mobile subscriptions and profiles for eSIM-ready consumer devices and wearables. This solution is compliant with the latest GSMA (Global System for Mobile Communications Association) standards to ensure global interoperability and, thanks to the scalability of the platform, the operator will be able to serve up to millions of customers during peak times. dtac subscribers now have the possibilit
CHMP Grants Positive Opinion for New Indication of Clovis Oncology’s Rubraca®▼ (rucaparib) Tablets as Maintenance Treatment for Women with Relapsed Ovarian Cancer13.12.2018 17:46 | Pressemelding
Clovis Oncology, Inc. (NASDAQ: CLVS) today announced that the European Union’s (EU) European Medicines Agency (EMA) Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (CHMP) has adopted a positive opinion recommending an additional indication to include rucaparib as monotherapy for the maintenance treatment of adult patients with platinum-sensitive relapsed high-grade epithelial ovarian, fallopian tube, or primary peritoneal cancer who are in response (complete or partial) to platinum-based chemotherapy. EC approval is anticipated in the first quarter of 2019. Once approved, Rubraca’s indication will expand beyond its initial Marketing Authorization in Europe granted in May 2018 for adult patients with platinum-sensitive, relapsed or progressive, BRCA mutated (germline and/or somatic), high-grade epithelial ovarian, fallopian tube, or primary peritoneal cancer, who have been treated with two or more prior lines of platinum-based chemotherapy, and who are unable to tolerate further platinum
Dole Food Company Sells Fresh Cut Business in Sweden and Finland13.12.2018 17:00 | Pressemelding
Dole Food Company, Inc., announced today an agreement to sell Saba Fresh Cuts AB and Saba Fresh Cuts OY to BAMA International. Saba Fresh Cuts AB—with production facility in Helsingborg Sweden—and Saba Fresh Cuts OY—with production facility in Espoo Finland—are producers of washed and ready-to-eat salads. The companies prepare and sell various fresh-cut salads and vegetables to the retail and foodservice industry in Sweden, Denmark, Finland, Germany and the Baltic States. The sale of Saba Fresh Cuts AB was a necessary condition of the European Commission’s approval of the investment by Total Produce into Dole in July 2018. “I am very pleased with the outcome of this sale in meeting the EU’s requirement,” said Mr. Johan Linden, President and Chief Executive Officer of Dole Food Company, “and I am confident that Saba Fresh Cuts will be in good hands under BAMA’s ownership.” "We are pleased to announce this agreement with Dole for Saba Fresh Cuts. Convenience products and ready-to-eat sal
Thales and Gemalto Are Granted Regulatory Clearance by the Commerce Commission in New Zealand13.12.2018 16:00 | Pressemelding
Regulatory News: Reference is made to the joint press release by Thales (Euronext Paris: HO) and Gemalto (Euronext Amsterdam and Paris: GTO) dated 27 March 2018 in relation to the launch of the recommended all-cash offer by Thales for all the issued and outstanding shares of Gemalto (the “Offer”), the publication of the Offer Document, and the joint press release of Thales and Gemalto dated 10 August 2018 in relation to the further extension of the Acceptance Period. Terms not defined in this press release will have the meaning as set forth in the Offer Document. Thales and Gemalto announce today that they have received merger control Regulatory Clearance from the Commerce Commission in New Zealand, following Thales’s commitment to divest its general purpose hardware security modules (GP HSM) business globally1 to a suitable purchaser. This clearance is effective immediately. Together with the antitrust clearances obtained in China, Israel, South Africa, Turkey, and for the European Un
Hurricane Electric Becomes First Internet Backbone to Connect to 200 Internet Exchanges around the Globe13.12.2018 15:37 | Pressemelding
Hurricane Electric, the world’s largest IPv6-native Internet backbone, today announced that it is the first Internet backbone in the world to connect to over 200 unique Internet exchanges. As an early leader in the switch to IPv6, Hurricane Electric now connects to the largest number of networks on the planet for both IPv6 and IPv4 and has been at the forefront of providing high-speed Internet connectivity to organizations throughout the world using:100GE (100 Gigabit Ethernet), 10GE (10 Gigabit Ethernet), and GigE (1 Gigabit Ethernet) connections. As a result of the improved connectivity with these 200 exchanges, customers receive the benefit of lower latency, higher throughput and increased fault tolerance. This reliable connectivity is especially important as global IP traffic continues to increase – Cisco’s Visual Networking Index: Forecast and Trends, 2017–2022 predicts that annual global IP traffic will reach 4.8 zettabytes (ZB) per year by 2022, or 396 exabytes (EB) per month, t
The World's Largest Heritage and Culture Festival to Begin With the Slogan Janadria 33 Faithfulness and Loyalty13.12.2018 15:15 | Pressemelding
With the support and under the patronage of the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Salman bin Abdulaziz, the 33rd Edition of the National Festival of Heritage and Culture will be held in Janadria for 21 days from Thursday 20th December 2018 to Wednesday 9th January 2019. Organized by the Saudi Ministry of National Guard, the festival is part of the efforts to intensify attention to Saudi heritage, expose it regionally and globally and to promote dialogue among cultures and civilizations on the level of people and nations. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20181213005472/en/ The Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Salman bin Abdulaziz (Photo: AETOSWire) Janadria is the largest Saudi cultural festival that simulates the history, present and future of Saudi Arabia and the largest event of its kind in the region. Since 1985, it has witnessed extensive Saudi participation, a growing Arab and Gulf presence and an